| Whipper Billy Watson & Pat Flanagan | 1952/08/28 | |
| Defeat Lord Athol Layton & Hans Hermann in tournament final to become champions. | ||
| Lou Plummer & Dick Raines | 1952/12/11 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Yvon Robert | 1953/06/25 | |
| Al Mills & Tiny Mills | 1953/11/26 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Hombre Montana | 1954/01/14 | |
| Al Mills & Tiny Mills [2] | 1954/02/11 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Tex McKenzie | 1954/06/02 | London |
| The Great Togo & Tosh Togo | 1954/07/08 | |
| Jack Claybourne & Luther Lindsay | 1954/10/28 | |
| Ivan Kalmikoff & Karol Kalmikoff | 1954/12/09 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Paul Baillargeon | 1954/12/30 | |
| Al Mills & Tiny Mills [3] | 1955/01/20 | |
| Ivan Kalmikoff & Karol Kalmikoff | 1955/03/17 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Lord Athol Layton | 1955/07/14 | |
| Fritz Von Erich & Karl Von Schober | 1955/10/25 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Ilio DiPaolo | 1955/12/12 | |
| Fritz Von Erich & Karl Von Schober [2] | 1955/12/29 | |
| Joe Brunetti & Guy Brunetti | 1956/08/16 | |
| Hard Boiled Haggerty & Dick Hutton | 1956/09/20 | |
| Joe Brunetti & Guy Brunetti [2] | 1956/09/27 | |
| Mr. Moto & Mr. Hito defeat the Brunetti Brothers via DQ on 56/10/25 in Toronto Both teams claim the titles. The Brunettis defeat Moto & Hito on 57/02/06 in Hamilton | ||
| Bill Miller & Ed Miller | 1957/02/12 | Hamilton |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Pat O'Connor | 1957/05/09 | |
| Gene Kiniski & Fritz Von Erich | 1957/10/31 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Yukon Eric | 1958/02/13 | |
| Reggie Lisowski & Stan Lisowski | 1958/03/20 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Bobo Brazil | 1958/05/22 | |
| Ivan Kalmikoff & Nikita Kalmikoff | 1958/06/12 | |
| Yukon Eric & Dara Singh | 1958/07/10 | |
| Reggie Lisowski & Stan Lisowski [2] | 1958/08/07 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Bernard Vignal | 1958/08/28 | |
| Ivan Kalmikoff & Nikita Kalmikoff [2] | 1958/09/24 | London |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Yukon Eric [2] | 1958/11/13 | |
| Gene Kiniski & Don Leo Jonathan | 1959/10/29 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Ilio DiPaolo [2] | 1959/12/31 | |
| Ivan Kalmikoff & Karol Kalmikoff | 1960/03/14 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Ilio DiPaolo [3] | 1960/04/21 | |
| Mike Gallagher & Doc Gallagher | 1960/08/11 | |
| Whipper Billy Watson & Ilio DiPaolo [3] | 1960/08/18 | |
| Tiny Mills & Stan Kowalski | 1960/12/29 | |
| Ilio DiPaolo & Billy Red Lyons | 1961/01/26 | |
| Title retired in 61/06 | ||
Toronto except where noted
